Each region quoted in its local currency — independent market readings, not FX conversions
The 456 market has bifurcated cleanly along transmission and generation lines. The ZF 4-speed automatic cars (GTA and M GTA) remain the accessible entry to a front-engined V12 Ferrari and trade in a $45,000–$65,000 band in the US — Bring a Trailer sold a 2002 456M GTA (Lot #199,407) at $49,250 in July 2025 and a 1997 456 GTA (Lot #188,485) at $65,000 in April 2025. Hagerty's US Price Guide currently lists a 1996 456 GT in #3 'Good' condition at $79,500 and a 2001 456M GT at $95,700 (both pages fetched directly), which is consistent with these prints.
The 6-speed manual market — especially the later 456M GT — is where the recent re-rating has happened. RM Sotheby's Monterey 2024 (Lot 147) sold a 21,345-mile Rosso Barchetta 1999 456M GT at $123,200 as a solidly-mid-tier example, and Bring a Trailer sold an 11,000-mile Grigio Titanio 2000 456M GT manual (Lot #237,745) at $156,000 in April 2026 as the current public high-water mark for a standard-production manual. RM Sotheby's Monterey 2024 (Lot 374) sold an exceptional 2,910-mile 1995 456 GT manual at $168,000 as a low-mileage outlier that sits above the standard market rather than within it.
In the UK, RHD manual cars remain the scarcest configuration (Bozhdynsky records 141 RHD 456 GT and 31 RHD 456M GT). Bonhams Goodwood 2021 (Lot 217) sold a RHD 1995 456 GT manual at £43,700 as a mid-market print at that time; The Classic Valuer's aggregated post-2020 data shows a median £49,572 for 456 GT sales and £79,124 for 456M GT sales, consistent with a modest ongoing manual-car re-rating rather than a step-change.
At the apex of the market, no Pininfarina Venice one-off has ever appeared publicly at auction and no verifiable public print exists for a documented Scaglietti Bicolore — both should be treated as private-treaty markets outside the public data set (see Collector Variants).